Try Again.

What happens after you say the wrong thing — and how to come back.

Smidgeon
A note for you
From Jennie · For parents only

Here's something I want you to sit with: repair is not just something you teach your child to do. It's something you model every time you do it yourself. The most powerful thing you can do for their emotional development this week is not the activity — it's what happens the next time you say the wrong thing to them, and you go back and say so.

Not a big production. Not a long explanation. Just: "I said that in a way that wasn't kind. I want to try again." Watch their face when you do it. That face is everything.

What's actually happening developmentally

Children this age are concrete learners. They absorb what they see far more than what they're told. When you repair with them — out loud, imperfectly, genuinely — you're showing them that repair is what people do. Not perfect people. Not other families. You. Which means they can too. The shame that makes repair so hard in adults is almost always learned from watching the adults around them refuse to do it.

Phrases that actually work in the moment
When your child has said something unkind
"I can see that landed hard. Can you try saying that again — a different way?"
When they're frozen and can't apologize yet
"You don't have to be ready right now. But before bed, we're going to circle back."
When the apology feels hollow or forced
"That's a start. Is there anything else you want to say?"
When you are the one who needs to repair
"I said that in a way that wasn't fair to you. I want to try again."
One thing to try this week

Let your child see you repair with someone else — your partner, a friend, even them. Don't explain it. Just do it out loud where they can hear. "Hey — I was short with you earlier and I didn't need to be. I'm sorry." That sentence, overheard, does more than any conversation about apologizing ever could.

📖 Smidgeon's Story
Read together or read first, then share
Smidgeon feeling frustrated
💥 Scene One · The Wrong Thing

Smidgeon did not mean to say it. But he said it anyway 😬.

Pip had built a picture out of sticks and leaves and one very good feather 🪶 she found near the fountain. She was proud of it. And Smidgeon looked at it and said —

Smidgeon
"That doesn't look like anything."

Pip's face went very still.

Smidgeon knew immediately. He had said the wrong thing.

His chest felt strange. Not angry. Not sad exactly. Something else — like he wanted to go back one minute and not say what he said.

Smidgeon feeling sad
🌧️ Scene Two · The Sitting With It

Pip walked away and sat by the big tree. She didn't look at Smidgeon.

Smidgeon stood where he was. The wrong thing was just hanging there in the air between them 😶.

Smidgeon — inside his head
"I should say sorry. But what if he's still too mad? What if sorry doesn't work? What if—"

He stood there for a long time.

The sorry didn't get easier the longer he waited. It just got heavier.


Smidgeon feeling loving
🌱 Scene Three · The Try Again

Smidgeon walked to the big tree 🌳. He sat down next to Pip. Not too close. Just close enough.

For a minute, neither of them said anything.

Then Smidgeon took a breath 🌬️.

Smidgeon
"I said something mean. I didn't mean to, but I did. I'm sorry."

Pip looked at him. A long look.

Pip
"It was the feather part I worked the hardest on."
Smidgeon
"I can see that now. It's a really good feather."
They sat under the tree until the light changed.

The wrong thing was still there. But now there was something else, too.
The try again. And the try again was bigger.
🎯 This Week's Activity
Do this together · 5–10 minutes

This one is called Try That Again. It's a simple game that makes repair feel like a skill — something you practice — not a punishment or a performance.

1
Set the stage together. You're going to act out a small, pretend mess-up. Something silly and low-stakes — "I knocked over your blocks on purpose" or "I grabbed the crayon without asking."
2
After the mess-up, you model the repair first. Say exactly what you'd want them to say: "I shouldn't have done that. I'm sorry. Can I try again?" Say it simply. Don't over-explain.
3
Switch. Let them play the mess-up role, and you play the hurt one. Let them practice saying it — in their own words. Don't script it for them. Prompt with: "What do you want to say?"
4
Finish by asking: "How does it feel when someone tries again after saying something that hurt?" Their answer will surprise you. Write it down.
👀 Watch for this

Notice whether your child relaxes when you model the repair — their shoulders, their breathing, their face. Relief is the emotion that repair produces. When they feel that relief, they're learning something that will travel with them: ruptures don't have to be permanent. People can come back to each other.

💜 Tell Me How It Went
3 questions · Honest answers only

Answer whatever feels most true. No right answers. Messy is useful. A single sentence is enough.

Thank you. Messy answers are the most useful ones. I read every single one. — Jennie